The Evolution of College Football: A Look at the Top Jobs in 2024
In the ever-evolving landscape of college football, the past three years have ushered in a wave of transformative changes. From seismic coaching shifts to conference realignment that has reshaped the sport’s geography, the dynamics of college football have been anything but static. The introduction of name, image, and likeness (NIL) rights, coupled with the freedom of movement afforded by the transfer portal, has completely altered the way programs manage their rosters. With these significant changes in mind, it’s an opportune moment to revisit a question posed three years ago: What are the top five jobs in college football?
To gain insight into this question, The Athletic conducted a poll of 50 individuals working within the college football ecosystem, including head coaches, general managers, assistant coaches, analysts, and recruiting staffers. The results reflect not only the prestige of certain programs but also the shifting priorities and values within the sport.
The Criteria for a Top Job
The appeal of a coaching position can vary widely depending on individual perspectives. For instance, one assistant coach highlighted Florida Atlantic for its “great location” and “not as much pressure,” while another pointed to Liberty for its “good facilities” and favorable schedule. Meanwhile, a general manager from a Power 4 program succinctly stated, “All that matters anymore is NIL and support.”
Despite the shifting landscape, the perennial powerhouses remain at the forefront. While the rankings may have changed, the core of the top five jobs continues to feature familiar names.
1. Georgia Bulldogs
Points: 173
First-place votes: 16
Total ballots: 43
Ranking in 2021: 3rd
Georgia has solidified its position as the premier job in college football, even after a recent loss to Alabama. The reasons for this are manifold. A Big Ten assistant encapsulated the allure of Georgia by citing its financial backing, donor support, state-of-the-art facilities, and a recruiting base that is second to none in the South. The Bulldogs have become a national powerhouse, winning back-to-back national championships in 2021 and 2022, and their recruiting prowess has only strengthened.
The state of Georgia has emerged as a talent-rich area, producing 152 blue-chip prospects over the last three recruiting cycles, surpassing traditional powerhouses like California. With Kirby Smart at the helm, Georgia operates with a level of efficiency and ambition that mirrors the dominance once exhibited by Nick Saban’s Alabama teams.
2. Texas Longhorns
Points: 155
First-place votes: 12
Total ballots: 45
Ranking in 2021: 3rd
Texas remains a tantalizing opportunity for coaches, boasting limitless potential. As the flagship university in a talent-rich state, Texas offers unparalleled resources, including NIL opportunities and top-tier facilities. The Longhorns have made significant strides in the NIL space, exemplified by an initiative that provides $50,000 annually to every scholarship offensive lineman.
The move to the SEC promises to further enhance the program’s financial standing, but internal politics and alignment have historically been hurdles. However, under Steve Sarkisian’s leadership, Texas is beginning to find its footing, winning the Big 12 in its final year in the conference and positioning itself as a contender in the SEC.
3. Ohio State Buckeyes
Points: 143
First-place votes: 8
Total ballots: 45
Ranking in 2021: 2nd
Ohio State has established itself as a consistent powerhouse, with a remarkable winning percentage across its last three coaches. Urban Meyer’s national recruiting strategy transformed the program, allowing the Buckeyes to attract top talent from across the country.
Despite Michigan’s recent resurgence, which served as a wake-up call for Ohio State, the Buckeyes have responded by ramping up their NIL efforts and securing crucial player retention. The combination of a national recruiting footprint and a strong NIL program keeps Ohio State firmly in the conversation for elite coaching jobs.
4. Alabama Crimson Tide
Points: 123
First-place votes: 6
Total ballots: 43
Ranking in 2021: 1st
Alabama’s legacy under Nick Saban is unmatched, but the question remains: what will the program look like post-Saban? The Crimson Tide still possess a strong recruiting appeal and a robust support system, but the expectations are daunting. Following in the footsteps of a coaching legend is no small feat, and the pressure to maintain Alabama’s elite status is palpable.
Kalen DeBoer has made strides since taking over, with Alabama currently boasting a top recruiting class. The foundation laid by Saban ensures that the program remains a top destination for coaches, even as it navigates the challenges of high expectations.
5. LSU Tigers
Points: 53
First-place votes: 3
Total ballots: 24
Ranking in 2021: 5th
LSU continues to be a formidable program, benefiting from its unique recruiting advantages within Louisiana. The Tigers have a strong track record of retaining top local talent, and their passionate fan base provides a significant boost. However, the pressure to win is immense, especially given the program’s history of success under previous coaches like Saban, Les Miles, and Ed Orgeron.
Brian Kelly’s first year saw LSU reach the SEC title game, but the expectation remains to compete for national championships. The unique culture and resources available at LSU make it a coveted position, but the stakes are high.
The Best of the Rest
While the top five jobs are well-established, several other programs are gaining traction. Oregon, USC, and Texas A&M received notable votes, highlighting their potential. Oregon, in particular, has seen its status rise significantly due to NIL, transforming it into a top-tier recruiting destination.
Texas A&M remains a sleeping giant, with unmatched resources and facilities, while USC’s market presence on the West Coast keeps it relevant in the national conversation.
As college football continues to evolve, the landscape of coaching opportunities will undoubtedly shift, but the allure of these top programs remains strong. The interplay of resources, talent, and expectations will continue to shape the future of the sport, making it an exciting time for coaches and fans alike.