The 2024 MLB Playoffs: Crafting American League Superteams
As the excitement builds for the 2024 MLB playoffs, fans and analysts alike are gearing up for what promises to be an exhilarating postseason. In a spirited exercise, FOX Sports’ Deesha Thosar and Rowan Kavner took on the challenge of drafting superteams from the best players remaining in the American League. This mock draft not only showcases the talent on display but also highlights the competitive banter between the two writers, making for an engaging read.
The Draft Format
The draft was structured to include eight position players, one designated hitter, four starting pitchers, and one closer. Thosar had the first pick for the American League, while Kavner took the lead for the National League draft. The linear format allowed for strategic selections, leading to a mix of star power and tactical choices.
Round 1: The Heavy Hitters
No. 1 (Thosar): Aaron Judge, Yankees CF
Thosar kicked off the draft with a bang, selecting Aaron Judge, the powerhouse outfielder known for his game-changing abilities. After a stellar season leading the majors in home runs, RBIs, OBP, and OPS, Judge is poised to be a postseason MVP. Thosar emphasized his clutch performance in high-pressure situations, making him an ideal first pick.
No. 2 (Kavner): Bobby Witt Jr., Royals SS
Kavner countered with Bobby Witt Jr., a dynamic player who brings a well-rounded skill set to the table. Kavner praised Witt’s ability to hit for average, slug, and excel defensively, making him a valuable asset at a premium position.
Round 2: The All-Stars
No. 3 (Thosar): José Ramírez, Guardians 3B
Thosar continued her strong draft with José Ramírez, a perennial All-Star and MVP candidate. Ramírez’s near 40/40 season showcases his elite status, and Thosar’s excitement was palpable as she secured one of the best third basemen in the game.
No. 4 (Kavner): Juan Soto, Yankees RF
Kavner’s selection of Juan Soto added another layer of offensive firepower to his team. With both Soto and Witt hitting over .340 with runners in scoring position, Kavner expressed confidence in his squad’s ability to produce runs.
Mid-Rounds: Strategic Picks
No. 5 (Thosar): Gunnar Henderson, Orioles SS
Thosar’s choice of Gunnar Henderson highlighted her strategy of building a competitive lineup. Henderson’s ability to get on base, slug, and play solid defense makes him a key player for her team.
No. 6 (Kavner): José Altuve, Astros 2B
Kavner opted for veteran presence with José Altuve, one of the all-time great postseason performers. Altuve’s experience and track record in the playoffs add a crucial element to Kavner’s roster.
The Pitching Duel
No. 9 (Thosar): Corbin Burnes, Orioles SP
Thosar’s selection of Corbin Burnes as her ace pitcher was a strategic move, especially with Burnes hitting free agency soon. His recent performance, including a 1.20 ERA in September, positions him as a dominant force in the playoffs.
No. 10 (Kavner): Yordan Alvarez, Astros DH
Kavner’s choice of Yordan Alvarez as his designated hitter showcased his focus on offensive production. With a career playoff OPS of .949, Alvarez is a dangerous bat that can change the course of a game.
The Final Rounds: Filling Out the Roster
As the draft progressed, both Thosar and Kavner made selections that reflected their strategies and preferences. Thosar rounded out her lineup with players like Anthony Santander and Emmanuel Clase, while Kavner secured talents like Riley Greene and Cade Smith.
Team Deesha’s Starting Lineup:
- Gunnar Henderson, SS
- Kyle Tucker, RF
- Aaron Judge, CF
- José Ramírez, 3B
- Kerry Carpenter, DH
- Salvador Perez, 1B
- Anthony Santander, LF
- Adley Rutschman, C
- Jazz Chisholm, 2B
SP1. Corbin Burnes
SP2. Gerrit Cole
SP3. Seth Lugo
SP4. Hunter Brown
Closer: Emmanuel Clase
Team Rowan’s Starting Lineup:
- José Altuve, 2B
- Juan Soto, RF
- Bobby Witt Jr., SS
- Yordan Alvarez, DH
- Josh Naylor, 1B
- Alex Bregman, 3B
- Riley Greene, LF
- Yainer Diaz, C
- Colton Cowser, CF
SP1. Tarik Skubal
SP2. Framber Valdez
SP3. Cole Ragans
SP4. Tanner Bibee
Closer: Cade Smith
The Banter and Rivalry
Throughout the draft, the friendly rivalry between Thosar and Kavner was evident. Their playful jabs and competitive spirit added an entertaining layer to the analysis, showcasing not just their expertise but also their passion for the game. The banter, filled with light-hearted insults and playful critiques, made the draft a lively affair.
As the 2024 MLB playoffs approach, fans can look forward to seeing how these superteams would perform in a hypothetical matchup. The excitement of the postseason, combined with the talent on display, promises to deliver unforgettable moments and thrilling baseball.